Rules of the Circle

1. The Circle is a review space

   Every discussion is tied to a claim, a comparison cell or a source in the Atlas. General discussions do not open here.

2. Every reply carries evidence

   A reply rests on a source with an exact locator, or is stated as personal testimony. A challenge or a proposed correction always needs a source.

3. Usage is not classification

   Usage notes from speakers are recorded and count for the names and local reality of a variety. They do not count as evidence for its place in a classification.

4. The editorial board decides

   No reply changes the Atlas by itself. The board decides, writes its reasons and publishes them in the corrections history.

5. The name goes with the contribution

   Every accepted contribution carries the name of the person who made it, if they allow it. Anyone who does not is credited as a member of the Circle.

6. No variety ranks above another

   The Atlas does not rank varieties as better or worse. We disagree with evidence, not with people or where they come from.

7. Taking on a question is a commitment

   When you take on a question, others see it as under review. If you cannot continue, release it.

8. Everything here is a draft

   Material in the Circle has not been approved for publication. Do not republish it or cite it as the position of the Atlas.